Top 5 Tips from Bahamian Marketers That Don't Show Up in Global Playbooks

Six months of @Work conversations — a state of the market

Six months ago, we started the @Work series with a simple premise: the people doing the most interesting marketing work in Corporate Bahamas rarely get asked about it publicly. We wanted to change that.

Since then, we've sat down with marketing leaders across insurance, retail, consumer goods, professional services, and destination marketing. Different industries. Different budgets. Different audiences. But the same handful of truths kept surfacing.

Here's what we heard.

1. Your most urgent marketing problem is probably a perception gap — and you already know what it is.

Every brand we spoke with is managing a distance between what they actually are and what some portion of the market still believes them to be

Brent Burrows II at CBS Bahamas had customers assuming high prices before they ever walked through the door. Maxine Seymour at Colina is translating 125 years of institutional trust into something meaningful for a 25-year-old. Maya Nottage at Nassau Cruise Port is working two directions at once, resetting international assumptions about Nassau while inviting Bahamians to see the port as theirs.

What's striking is that none of them are waiting for a campaign to fix it. They're reaching customers before the misconception can take hold. They're showing proof before the objection is raised. They're building the argument before the conversation even starts.

The perception gap is usually not a secret inside your organization. The question is whether you're actively closing it or hoping the market eventually catches up to reality on its own.

2. Trust is built in the details, not the declarations.

‍
Karla Wells-Lisgaris at Caribbean Bottling Company talks about coolers. The cooler sitting in the corner of a small shop: is it clean? Is the light working? Is the product faced properly? "Those small details," she said, "signal that if we care about a cooler, we also care about product quality and everything behind it."

Brent's team at CBS operates under a rule: no one leaves without an answer. A floor staff member who can't answer a question doesn't say, "That's not my department." They take responsibility for finding someone who can. That's a policy, but it's also a culture, which is what makes a policy real.

In a market this size, the brand experience delivered by your front-line team is your marketing. The campaign sets the expectation. The cooler, the callback, the quote, the staff member who stayed on the phone — that's what confirms it or contradicts it.

‍‍
3. Local is a strategy, not a checkbox.

Several of our guests operate under global parent brands. Every single one of them arrived at the same answer about what actually connects in this market: you take what the global gives you like resources, credibility, creative infrastructure — and you make it unmistakably local.

When Karla's team brought the "Share a Coke" campaign to The Bahamas, their job wasn't to execute the global idea. It was to make it Bahamian. That meant digging into the ranking of popular local names and selecting the ones people here would actually find on a bottle. Neveah. Zion. Jamal. Tino. "People like to see themselves reflected," she said.

Maya's team at Nassau Cruise Port works with creators who are already trusted by local audiences, and they lead with identity, not just content. "Nassau Cruise Port is a Bahamian company, and we employ Bahamians," she said, "so our identity is not something we add on at the end. It is at the center of how we tell our story."

The competitive advantage available to any Caribbean brand is exactly this: global resources amplified through local relevance. It's the one thing a company headquartered outside the region cannot easily replicate.

4. The metrics that matter most don't always live in a dashboard.

‍
Every leader we spoke with uses data rigorously. Maya's team runs guest surveys daily. Mieko Smith at PwC reviews LinkedIn analytics monthly and meets quarterly with service line leaders to align content with business goals. Maxine tracks client information completion rates alongside campaign reach.

But every one of them also named something that sits outside the spreadsheet.

Mieko tracks LinkedIn performance closely, but the signal she keeps coming back to is whether someone stopped her in a food store to mention a post. Not an impression. A real person, in a real place, who said I saw that, and it stayed with me. Partners and team members were getting the same feedback at the gym and at the supermarket.

Karla said it directly: "You have to make money at the end of the day, but community response and organic amplification are also important signs of success."

In a market where networks are dense and word of mouth still travels faster than any paid channel, the most valuable signal you can receive is an unprompted referral. That is not a soft metric. That is the whole game.

5. Reputation is not a campaign outcome. It's an accumulation.

‍
The brands that showed up in our conversations with the deepest trust in the market did not build it through a single launch or a rebrand moment. They built it through consistency, through what they did when no one was watching, through the commitments they kept when it was inconvenient, through the years of showing up the same way.

Mieko's brand refresh at PwC was an internal and external signal that the firm was entering a new era. But the signal only lands if the work behind it changes, too. The visual is the promise. The team delivers on it.

Maxine at Colina doesn't dismiss heritage. She translates it. What does 125 years of trust actually mean to someone today? Not as an abstract value. As a proof point they can feel in how a claim gets handled, how a conversation goes, and how a product works when you actually need it.

Reputation is the long game. In this market, it is also the only game worth playing because it cannot be bought quickly, and definitely not be faked at scale.

Six months in

‍
What we've built through @Work is a record of how the best marketing minds in this market actually think. Not theory. Not global frameworks retrofitted for The Bahamas. The real thing.

We'll keep building it. If you're doing interesting work in this space or know someone who is, we'd love to hear from you.

hello@onwrdadvisors.com

ONWRD Advisors @Work is an ongoing series exploring marketing and communications leadership across The Bahamas and the Caribbean.